Before renewing your COE, compare keeping your current car with replacing it over the same period. Confirm renewal eligibility, obtain the applicable PQP and assess the work your car needs. Then compare cash required, running costs and realistic exit assumptions. A smaller upfront renewal payment alone does not establish the better choice.

Calculator, stacked coins and financial planning papers
Cost-planning illustration from StarBright Auto’s media collection, not COE price data. Use the worksheet below to compare renewal and replacement over the same ownership period.

This worksheet is for owners of ordinary Category A or B private cars approaching a renewal decision. Different rules can apply to other vehicle types and schemes. If you are comparing cars to buy instead, start with our used-car depreciation guide.

First establish which renewal options remain available

Check your vehicle’s category, COE expiry and renewal history against LTA’s COE renewal guidance. For Category A and B cars, a five-year renewal costs 50% of the applicable PQP, rounded up to the nearest dollar, and can be taken only once. The car must be deregistered when that five-year period ends. A ten-year renewal costs the full PQP; eligible cars without a statutory lifespan may renew in further ten-year periods.

Category A/B renewal choices, based on LTA guidance

Category A/B renewal choices, based on LTA guidance
ChoiceDecision to resolve
Five-year renewalDoes a final five-year period fit your plans? Do not budget for another renewal afterwards.
Ten-year renewalCan you fund the larger upfront payment while retaining a sensible repair reserve?
Replace the carWhat suitable alternative can you actually buy, and what are its condition and ownership costs?

On a small screen, scroll the table sideways to see every column.

PQP changes monthly. Use the rate applicable to your intended renewal, not an old article’s price. Renewing early can forfeit unused COE. LTA allows late renewal within one month subject to its conditions and a fee, but an expired COE does not permit continued road use. Plan before expiry.

Get a condition assessment before committing the renewal money

Ask a qualified workshop for a written assessment of your particular car. Separate immediate repairs from scheduled maintenance and uncertain findings that need further diagnosis. A recent service invoice is useful evidence, but it does not answer every question about the next several years.

  • Which repairs are necessary now, and what do the written quotations include?
  • What servicing is due by time or mileage during your intended ownership period?
  • Which significant systems were not assessed?
  • Would potential downtime disrupt work, school runs or care arrangements?

You can review StarBright Auto’s Warranty & Workshop information and ask whether an assessment suitable for your car is available. Do not treat workshop services as a promise that future repairs will be covered.

Build one comparison using the same ownership period

Choose a comparison period first, such as three years. Then complete both columns using dated quotations and clearly labelled assumptions. Keep the car’s eventual sale value separate from money already available today.

Owner’s renewal-versus-replacement worksheet

Owner’s renewal-versus-replacement worksheet
InputKeep your carReplace it
Starting paymentApplicable renewal payment and immediate workReplacement purchase price and required fees
Current-car proceedsNo sale proceeds while you retain itConfirmed net sale/disposal proceeds
Running costsInsurance, tax, energy, parking and servicingThe same categories for the exact alternative
BorrowingInterest and fees, if applicableInterest and fees, if applicable
Exit assumptionEstimated net value at the chosen end dateEstimated net value at that same end date

On a small screen, scroll the table sideways to see every column.

For a forward-looking cash comparison, total each route’s future payments, subtract proceeds actually received along that route, then subtract its assumed net exit value. Do not also charge the retained car’s current value to the renewal route if you have already credited that value as sale proceeds in the replacement route. That would count the same opportunity twice.

If finance is outstanding, reconcile settlement and loan balances consistently. Do not combine full purchase prices with repayments of the same principal. Our quotation comparison guide explains the distinction between total cost and cash flow.

Stress-test the decision, not just the headline payment

Illustrative example only: suppose your completed three-year worksheet gives S$45,000 for renewal and S$48,000 for replacement, after each route’s assumed net exit value. These are invented teaching figures, not PQP rates, market quotations or StarBright Auto prices.

What changes a hypothetical S$3,000 advantage?

What changes a hypothetical S$3,000 advantage?
ScenarioResult
Original assumptionsRenewal is S$3,000 lower.
Renewal route needs S$4,000 more repairsRenewal becomes S$49,000, or S$1,000 higher.
Instead, replacement exit value is S$5,000 lowerReplacement becomes S$53,000, or S$8,000 higher.

On a small screen, scroll the table sideways to see every column.

The second and third rows are separate tests, not simultaneous predictions. Test the assumptions you are least confident about. A narrow apparent saving is less useful when it depends on an unverified repair estimate or optimistic resale figure.

Check rebates and ageing-car costs separately

Use LTA’s PARF and COE rebate guidance for your vehicle and proposed dates. An eligible PARF rebate depends on meeting the applicable conditions and age limit; do not assume it remains available after keeping the car beyond ten years. A possible unused-COE rebate is a separate calculation, not a guaranteed market selling price. If a disposal or trade-in quotation already includes rebates, do not add them again.

LTA’s road-tax guidance also sets an age-related surcharge for vehicles over ten years: it starts at 10% and rises with age to 50% for vehicles over fourteen years. Obtain the actual payable amount for your car rather than extending last year’s road tax unchanged.

Make the decision with three checks

  1. Eligibility: the renewal choice is available and you understand the deadline.
  2. Usability: your car still meets your needs, with its condition and known work assessed.
  3. Affordability: the upfront payment, running costs and a repair contingency remain manageable under a less favourable scenario.

If your household’s needs have changed, compare suitable alternatives rather than a hypothetical cheaper car. Our seven-seater family-car guide can help you assess passenger and luggage requirements before reviewing current pre-owned listings.

Frequently asked questions

Is five-year renewal cheaper overall?

Its upfront PQP payment is lower, but total ownership cost also depends on repairs, running costs and your planned exit. Compare the same period and account for the finality of that renewal.

Should I renew because I recently paid for a major repair?

That repair may improve the car’s condition, but money already spent should not be added again to future costs. Use the repair record as evidence when assessing what remains to be done.

Can I use today’s selling price as my future exit value?

No. It can inform your assumptions, but future value is uncertain. Test a lower outcome and keep a documented rebate enquiry distinct from a dealer’s purchase offer.

Sources checked: 8 November 2026. This is general decision guidance, not a vehicle valuation or personalised financial recommendation.

Compare renewal with a real replacement option.

Identify a suitable listing and request its vehicle details and an itemised quotation before completing your comparison.